Mental Health

Living with Uncertainty; Electing Mindfulness

It is no surprise that many people—patients and acquaintances—have been talking with me about the anxiety they feel in response to the rhetoric of the current election cycle.  Indeed, the divisive language that is daily bandied about, coupled with very real domestic and international challenges, contributes to creating a perfect storm for anxiety and worse.  Many people report that they both obsess about and feel compelled to follow the latest declamations of the candidates, which heighten their discomfort:  anger, a common response to the day’s rhetoric, activates further anxiety.  A friend told me that her anxiety is so high that she believes it is affecting her health.  Regardless of where you stand on the political spectrum, the heated rhetoric is certainly having an effect not only on social discourse, but on our mental and physical health. 

I’ve been encouraging patients to limit their exposure to the news cycle on television and the internet.  Social media, with all its memes, often creates an echo chamber where we are constantly exposed to political messaging which activates and reinforces anger, feelings of helplessness, and anxiety.  The purpose of self-limiting choices is not to bury your head in the sand but to manage anxiety.  Find a balance that works for you.

However, there is a deeper challenge that arises:  how to live with uncertainty?

The reality is that none of us knows what the outcome of this particular election cycle will be.  Indeed, none of us knows what the next moment will bring.  None of us has sufficient power alone to control for a particular political outcome.  We are all subject to forces that are much larger than any one of us. 

In my view, there are psychological strategies—attitudes and ways of thinking—that can help you manage the anxiety concomitant to living with uncertainty.  At the foundation of them all is an honest assessment of your personal power and your place within the larger scheme of life. 

Each of us has personal power, although it is not always easy to discern where it lies at any given moment, nor how best to exercise it.   And when you’re feeling anxious, it is easy to forget that you have personal power—or misuse it. 

Your power lies in your ability to choose your response to what is arising in this moment.

Simple, but easy to forget.

Mindfulness is a very useful means for responding to uncertainty.  Mindfulness focuses attention and helps you develop clarity about what, if anything, needs to be done right now.  (See my blog, “Do What This Moment Requires” [July 12, 2016] for more.)   Mindfulness brings laser-sharp attention to this moment—here-and-now.  Further, mindfulness can help you become aware of what you might be adding to your anxiety.

There can be a number of impediments to mindfulness, though.  Old patterns of thinking, old beliefs (especially your beliefs about your power), substance use, and trauma all impact your ability to develop clarity and mindfulness.  Psychotherapy supports mindfulness by identifying and working through those impediments.

Beyond this, it seems to me that there are a number of decisions or actions you can take not just in this moment but over the next few months.  Several acquaintances have chosen to channel their anxiety into activism for social justice.  A couple of artists I know are channeling their responses into creating art that gives voice to their values and beliefs.  Another acquaintance is volunteering for a local political campaign.  Taking committed action can be a very powerful response to living with uncertainty. 

How will you choose to respond?

Quality Time, Online Time, and You

An increasingly common session opener:  a client enters my office and reports that he hasn’t slept because he spent most of the previous night online watching YouTube videos, looking at Instagram, and reading Facebook posts.  He didn't intend to spend so much time online.  And he asks (more of himself than of me) “What am I doing?”  He is tired and exasperated with himself, largely because this is not the first time he’s lost an entire night to the internet.  Then he added:  “I’m not getting what I want because I get distracted by what’s online.”

My response to him:  “I suspect that you hoped that surfing the web would give you something, that it would do something for you. I wonder what you are being distracted from. What is it that you want to "get"?  Let’s try to explore and understand what you need.”

As wonderful as online connectivity can be, the number of patients who report spending hours on their computers, tablets, or phones during unstructured time is increasing—and they’re not necessarily happy about this.  Surfing the web, watching YouTube, looking at Instagram or scrolling through Facebook posts on your smartphone has become a means of spending time when you’re between tasks or when you just don’t know what to do with yourself.  Apps have become a way of distracting yourself, disconnecting from feelings, filling time, and mediating relationships. 

Many clients admit to losing hours to YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, Tumblr, Hulu, online pornography, and other entertainments.  Most of these clients complain of feeling drained and somewhat disoriented at the end of their online sessions.  Many also note that they have difficulty sleeping when they go offline.  They are both tired and hyped up, depressed and agitated.  Nearly all complain of failing to accomplish tasks or goals.  Nearly all complain of feeling dissatisfied with the quality of their family, marital or social relationships--not enough "face time", not enough quality time, not enough meaningful connection.

As an artist friend commented, “the internet, with all its bells and whistles, has become the latest thief that robs people of time, creativity, and relationships.”

Other commentators have written extensively about the ironic loneliness that many people feel in this age of social media.  Although we seem to be are more connected than ever, many people feel more isolated, lonely, and unfulfilled than ever.

Perhaps it is because we are connecting with machines instead of people.

This blog is not about the ‘perils’ of the internet.  (Indeed, I’m quite aware of how I am using the internet to talk about mental health and to contribute to a larger conversation about aspects of wellness and healing.)  Rather, this blog IS about the decisions you make about how you use your unstructured time and what may be driving those decisions.  This blog IS about how you make the choices that energize or deplete you.

Ask yourself this:  how do you feel when you unexpectedly face a block of unstructured time?  Think longer and deeper:  after the initial frisson of anticipation, what comes up?  And then, be honest with yourself:  what do you actually do with that free time?  How often do you go online?  How much time do you spend there?

For many, unstructured time—especially unstructured time spent alone--evokes anxiety:  an open stretch of time elicits fears of the unknown and emptiness.  Questions arise—often emerging from the murk of our unconscious:  What am I doing with my life?  With whom do I connect? What would make me happier?  What do I need?  How do I get my deepest needs met?  Why do I feel dissatisfied?  You are suddenly faced with yourself—warts and all—and feel compelled to react to whatever it is that makes you feel uncomfortable. 

Unstructured time also presents you with opportunities to honestly look at yourself and ask why you do what you do.  Unstructured time can bring you face to face with your vulnerabilities, your need to connect with others, and perhaps your unacknowledged ambivalence about  doing so.  After all, relationships are, by their very nature, experiences with vulnerability.

It seems to me that there is indeed choice to be made when you encounter a stretch of unstructured time:  you can wake up, meaningfully take action to creatively connect with your deepest self and others; or you can “go to sleep” by distracting yourself with passive entertainments.  Many people reach for a distraction.  Many would rather check out than check in.

From my perspective, depression and anxiety seem to correlate with the number of hours people spend ‘checked out’ online.  (This is my observation, and I do not have hard statistics to support this claim.) Passive entertainments tend not to engage one’s whole being.  On the other hand, creative actions taken in relationship with others engage us as whole persons and tend to connect us more meaningfully with others. 

There is a paradox to creative activity and connection:  while it requires effort, taking creative action to connect with yourself and others is energizing.  You feel good when you’ve been engaged in a meaningfully productive activity or an activity that brings you face-to-face with others.  When you’re creative, you plug into a vital source of energy—indeed, a life force. 

And so, the choice is yours.  In the words of poet Mary Oliver:  “Tell me, what is it you plan to do with your one wild and precious life?”